Synthesis Employing 2 Options Johnson vs Carr Composition

Synthesis Applying Two Resources

Which do you think is much better; what we see on the television screens or what we should see in our computer system screens? In Steven Johnson's, " Watching TV Makes You Smarter, ” and Nicholas Carr's, " Is usually Google Producing Us Ridiculous? ” the two authors focus on the ways multimedia have altered the way we all learn nowadays; Johnson states that television is having a positive effect on world and, actually is making us better, while Carr contends that media, particularly the internet, limits our potential for, " deep thought. ” Meeks and Carr's articles equally examine the change in our society through the cognitive effects of today's media. Johnson explains how the complexity of media like, television set and video gaming, are aiding kids multi-task, and think more deeply, as a result becoming wiser. Johnson says, " The youngsters are forced to consider like grown-ups: analyzing sophisticated social networks, managing resources, tracking subtle narrative intertwinings, recognizing long-term patterns”(229). This shows Johnson's idea that some of the abilities learned by simply kids today, through tv set and video games are useful in other avenues and later on in life. Carr gives all of us his personal examples of within media and their positive effects in the expansion expertise. Carr explains throughout the span of history, great minds have feared transform; he speaks of Socrates and his bother about the crafted word, Carr tells us, " He wasn't able to foresee the numerous ways that producing and examining would serve to spread info, spur new ideas, and expand man knowledge (if not wisdom)”(970). We are able to visit a parallel among Jonson's description of mental labor and skills discovered and Carr's discussion of growing information, spurring fresh tips and increasing human knowledge. We also find that Johnson and Carr do not always agree on every thing when it comes to mass media. Johnson feels the complexity in modern television shows story...

Cited: Carr, Nicholas. " Is Yahoo Making All of us Stupid? ” The Norton Field Guide to Writing with Readings. Second Edition. Bullok, Richard, Maureen Daly Goggin, New York: Norton, 2010. 961-973. Print

Meeks, Steven. " Watching TV Enables you to Smarter. ” They Say as well as I Say with Readings. Initial Edition. Graff, Gerald, Cathy Birkenstein, Russel Durst, Nyc: Norton, 2009. 213-230. Produce.